April 17, 2013

BSC #116, Abby and the Best Kid Ever: The Kids Aren’t All Right

Posted in books tagged , , at 6:24 pm by Jenn

The cover artist couldn't pick ONE scene from this book to illustrate? This one makes no sense!

The cover artist couldn’t pick ONE scene from this book to illustrate? This one makes no sense!

Summary: Lou from Kristy and the Worst Kid Ever is back in town, having been adopted (along with her older brother) by her aunt and uncle. And she’s completely different. Not only is she not bratty, whiny, grouchy, or rude, but she’s the exact opposite. Take the most well-behaved, polite child you can think of, then double it, and you have Lou.

Unfortunately, she’s not as great as she sounds. She goes so overboard with trying to please people that she gets on their nerves instead. Abby’s working on a big project for Black History Month, with a bunch of kids helping, and Lou’s desire to please actually has the opposite effect. She ends up screwing things up, and Abby’s so annoyed that she snaps at her.

Lou’s behavior continues like this until one day she accidentally breaks one of her aunt and uncle’s plates. She panics and admits that she’s worried they’ll send her away. As has been clear from the first page she appeared on in this book, Lou is overdoing the niceness because she’s afraid of being taken back to foster care. (And if that doesn’t break your heart, then I’d like to know what shade of black your heart is.) Her aunt and uncle assure her that they love her and want her around no matter how she acts.

The B-plot involves a very un-Lou-like kid, Sean Addison. The Addisons are moving to Seattle, and Sean is grumpy because he doesn’t think anyone will miss him. Which they probably won’t, because he’s a brat. Part of this stems from the whole library thing with Mary Anne. Some of the BSC girls try to spend the day with him, letting him do whatever he wants, but he gets the impression that they only hung out with him because they felt obligated. The whole thing doesn’t really get resolved, but it’s not like it matters, since the family’s moving across the country. Then we meet the Nichollses, the family moving into the Addisons’ house, and the BSC girls get a weird vibe from the father. But that’s for another book.

The C-plot (I guess) is about Abby’s project, which she stresses about because she needs a good grade. She can’t decide what to focus on until Nicky Pike suggests the Underground Railroad, since the Spiers’/Schafers’ house was supposedly a stop. (I thought this was nice continuity from past books where we were told he likes to hang out in Dawn’s secret passageway.) Eventually Abby makes a fake news report about an escaped slave and includes some behind-the-scenes footage. It sounds like she did a ton of work and wound up with a great result.

Thoughts: Mallory does her Black History Month project on “deconstruction of Uncle Tom’s Cabin from 1852 until now.” Um, NO. She’s in sixth grade. There’s no way she knows what deconstruction is. (Also, after all the lit theory discussions I had in college, that word makes me cringe. But not as much as “post-modern” makes me cringe.)

Claudia and Corrie work on a project that’s actually pretty cool. They make a big mural of Stoneybrook and put in people and places Corrie will want to remember after she moves. I also love that they draw Kristy’s grandmother’s car, the Pink Clinker, speeding down the street with the police chasing her.

“I wasn’t the new kid anymore.” No kidding, Abby. You’ve been in the series for two years and you’ve had more books than Mallory and Jessi combined during that time.


  1. Cassie said,

    I saw your blog in the “book” category and noticed The Babysitter’s Club image and was immediately clicking. I LOVED these books as a kid. SO HAPPY you reviewed this one! : )

    • bscag said,

      Cassie, you should go through and read all of her reviews; they’re great!

  2. kate said,

    The Pink Clinker! Wow, I forgot about that little detail.

    And the implausibility of Mallory’s project cracks me up. I wonder if the ghostwriter threw stuff like that in just to amuse him/herself. I think you might have to do that if you were writing a lot of these books.

  3. bscag said,

    Abby ends up narrating eleven books by the end of the series. Jessi narrates fourteen and Mallory narrates thirteen. Shannon gets one; Logan gets two.

    Not including her three California Diaries, Dawn narrates 22 books. Claudia, Kristy, and Mary Anne get 31, and Stacey wins with 32.

    Considering that Mallory joined in book 14, I think it says something that she narrates the least amount of books of the full members, even taking into account that she and Jessi each only get one mystery. And Mallory’s the one who gets severe mono, can’t go to Hawaii, etc etc. I think there’s a decent amount of evidence that Mallory was Ann’s un-favorite. There was an interview with Ann that had her speculating what each girl would grow up to be, and she couldn’t think of anything for Mallory!

  4. Caroline Elizabeth Annalise Avery said,

    In this book, when the McNallys and her family move in, Mr Papadakis and his family come over to help, Abby watches five kids, even though the BSC rule is that nobody watches more than four kids at the time.

    • Jenn said,

      Maybe they considered that okay because there were adults nearby in case Abby needed help.

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: